Feyenoord Forum » Algemeen Feyenoord Forum » Business Law

Starting a business is exciting — full of ideas, energy, and vision. But not all ventures go as planned. Sometimes, due to various reasons — be it financial, operational, or personal — continuing the business may no longer be viable. In such cases, opting for closure through proper legal procedures is a smart and responsible move.

In India, both Limited Liability Partnerships (LLPs) and Private Limited Companies (PLCs) can be wound up voluntarily or compulsorily, depending on the situation. This article simplifies the winding-up scenarios, explains relevant provisions, and provides clarity on when it’s best to opt for closure.

Understanding Business Closure: LLP vs. Private Limited Company
Before we dive into the winding-up process, let’s quickly understand the basic difference:

LLP (Limited Liability Partnership) is governed by the LLP Act, 2008. It's ideal for professionals or small business partnerships that need flexibility and limited liability.

Private Limited Company is governed by the Companies Act, 2013. It’s suitable for startups or businesses that intend to scale with investors.

Both structures offer limited liability, but their closure process differs slightly in complexity and cost.

When Should You Consider Closure?
- No Business Activity
If your LLP or company hasn't commenced operations since incorporation or has been inactive for two consecutive financial years, closure is recommended to avoid unnecessary compliance costs.

- Consistent Financial Losses
If the business is running in losses, has no scope for recovery, or the liabilities exceed assets, closure is a practical route to avoid creditor litigation.

- Founders’ Mutual Decision
When partners/shareholders mutually decide not to continue the business — maybe due to relocation, career shift, or retirement — winding up is the cleanest way to exit.

- Regulatory Non-Compliance
If the entity has failed to file annual returns, financial statements, or other mandatory documents, and reviving compliance is too costly or unnecessary, closure helps reduce penalties.

- Change in Business Model
If the structure no longer fits the business needs — for instance, you started as a company but want to switch to a sole proprietorship — winding up the current structure is necessary.

Closure Process for LLP
- Fast Track Exit under Rule 37 of LLP Rules, 2009

Applicable when:

LLP is not carrying on any business for at least one year.

Has no outstanding liabilities.

- Documents Required:

Board resolution by partners

Consent of all partners

Affidavit and indemnity bond

ITR acknowledgment (if filed)

Statement of accounts certified by CA

- Relevant Provision:

Rule 37 of LLP Rules, 2009

Section 63, 64, and 65 of LLP Act, 2008

The LLP can apply for closure via Form 24 to the Registrar of Companies (ROC).

Closure Process for Private Limited Company
Strike Off under Section 248 of Companies Act, 2013
Applicable when:

Company hasn’t commenced operations within one year OR

Inactive for the last two financial years AND not filed for dormant status.

- Documents Required:

Board and shareholders’ resolutions

Indemnity bond and affidavit

Statement of assets and liabilities certified by CA

ITR and bank closure letter

- Relevant Provision:

Section 248(2) of the Companies Act, 2013

Companies (Removal of Names of Companies) Rules, 2016

Application is filed using Form STK-2.

Voluntary Winding Up under Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC)
Used when:

Company has liabilities it cannot pay off

Wants to liquidate under supervision of insolvency professionals

- Provision:

Section 59 of Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016

This method is lengthy and suited for companies with significant assets and liabilities.

Key Differences in Closure: LLP vs. Pvt Ltd
Criteria LLP Closure Pvt Ltd Closure
Governing Law LLP Act, 2008 Companies Act, 2013 / IBC, 2016
Form Used Form 24 Form STK-2 / IBC forms
Eligibility Inactive for 1+ year, no dues Inactive for 2+ years or no business
Approval Required Consent of all partners 75% shareholder consent
Time Taken 2–6 months 3–9 months
Professional Certification Yes (CA/CS) Yes (CA/CS)
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
- Can I close my LLP without filing annual returns?

No. You must file overdue returns before closure unless it was never operational. In some cases, condonation of delay may be required.

- Can I revive a company after strike-off?

Yes, within 20 years, by applying to the NCLT under Section 252 of the Companies Act, 2013.

- What happens to assets and liabilities at the time of closure?

All assets must be sold, and liabilities cleared before closure. If liabilities exist, voluntary liquidation under IBC is required.

- Is closure cheaper than compliance?

Yes. If you're not operating the business, closure is far more economical than continuing with annual ROC filings, audits, and other statutory compliance.

- Can a single partner LLP be closed?

Yes, but it must be converted into a sole proprietorship or follow the proper closure procedure as per the LLP Act.

- Do I need to file GST returns before closure?

Yes. All pending GST returns and cancellation of GST registration must be completed before winding up.

Final Thoughts
Knowing when to pull the plug on your LLP or private limited company is a tough but necessary business decision. Avoiding closure due to sentimentality or paperwork fear may cost you penalties, legal notices, or loss of goodwill. Whether your entity is inactive, unprofitable, or no longer aligned with your goals — opting for formal winding-up ensures peace of mind, legal compliance, and a clean financial exit.

Bron: When to Opt for Closure: LLP and Private Limited Company Winding Up Scenarios

+1/-0